{ "recordId": "CJ-TR-20261104", "version": "1.4", "publicEditionNote": "2026-11-07: public edition of 1.3; host name removed from the memo cover line; exhibits and hashes unchanged.", "compiledAt": "2026-11-04T13:35:05.774463+00:00", "date": "2026-11-04", "purpose": "Presentation demonstration testing memorandum and exhibit schedule", "compiler": "Codex with AI assistance; prepared for Sam Rogers", "modelResponseCount": 31, "perplexityPairedRunCount": 0, "runs": [ { "id": "CJ-CL-A1", "provider": "Claude", "run": "A1", "condition": "Plain A", "timestamp": "2026-11-04T12:23:10.881Z", "timestampMeaning": "response captured", "localTime": "2026-11-04 05:23:10 MST", "modelLabel": "Model: Opus 5.5 Medium", "account": "Claude Max, personal", "search": "Visible web search", "sourceFile": "review/demo-runs-2026-11-04/A1.json", "originalJsonSha256": "13ee971a11092b44d334ea4bd65e0eba186e47e07f9a351f858c86956c048f7b", "transcriptSha256": "7faf105c01d41046cac7be637bbf56ed11b37bf872a90fcf6e364e2a488a6bfa", "promptSha256": "6b74e7bea8c56c08450212e60d0da261d359a893431c7d04cedf4b837281e403", "finding": "Garner found; Rule 3.3 intent misread.", "exhibit": "exhibits/CJ-CL-A1.html", "responseLineCount": 39 }, { "id": "CJ-CL-A2", "provider": "Claude", "run": "A2", "condition": "Plain A", "timestamp": "2026-11-04T12:25:29.232Z", "timestampMeaning": "response captured", "localTime": "2026-11-04 05:25:29 MST", "modelLabel": "Model: Opus 5.5 Medium", "account": "Claude Max, personal", "search": "Visible web search", "sourceFile": "review/demo-runs-2026-11-04/A2.json", "originalJsonSha256": "63e8144e0adf3659544e5af032fb0a5b6de423bb4e4c0cbf675b5946752fe4c8", "transcriptSha256": "8cd59dcddb76acd05637adbb284264a26d0463c7c719c816699de37ee7248b48", "promptSha256": "6b74e7bea8c56c08450212e60d0da261d359a893431c7d04cedf4b837281e403", "finding": "Same Rule 3.3 recklessness assertion.", "exhibit": "exhibits/CJ-CL-A2.html", "responseLineCount": 46 }, { "id": "CJ-CL-A3", "provider": "Claude", "run": "A3", "condition": "Plain A", "timestamp": "2026-11-04T12:27:12.268Z", "timestampMeaning": "response captured", "localTime": "2026-11-04 05:27:12 MST", "modelLabel": "Model: Opus 5.5 Medium", "account": "Claude Max, personal", "search": "Visible web search", "sourceFile": "review/demo-runs-2026-11-04/A3.json", "originalJsonSha256": "f012c528a4bf88fbe954f05ce43d6567c2b7e0db608a333e98035e4aa328765b", "transcriptSha256": "36376c869cb2fda571e997804850f7179c3a7e8056ea2df2a49f2dd133706800", "promptSha256": "6b74e7bea8c56c08450212e60d0da261d359a893431c7d04cedf4b837281e403", "finding": "Rule 40 outcome described; Rule 5.3 added analysis.", "exhibit": "exhibits/CJ-CL-A3.html", "responseLineCount": 47 }, { "id": "CJ-CL-P1", "provider": "Claude", "run": "P1", "condition": "Structured A-prime", "timestamp": "2026-11-04T12:34:10.710Z", "timestampMeaning": "response captured", "localTime": "2026-11-04 05:34:10 MST", "modelLabel": "Model: Opus 5.5 Medium", "account": "Claude Max, personal", "search": "Visible web search", "sourceFile": "review/demo-runs-2026-11-04/Claude-P1.json", "originalJsonSha256": "bf1e7dd26c0854ec2dae84be911a0b4710296c5498b86779be2914b438bd1258", "transcriptSha256": "56eaf1121cf336ee29c0afa74f36a25476df43590faede7850bf6108331d864b", "promptSha256": "934d5322733232d72c85b57d9eba2fbd3b179f3baeeea4ff915e4a5c3bb39167", "finding": "Footnote 4 intent distinction quoted correctly.", "exhibit": "exhibits/CJ-CL-P1.html", "responseLineCount": 85 }, { "id": "CJ-CL-P2", "provider": "Claude", "run": "P2", "condition": "Structured A-prime", "timestamp": "2026-11-04T12:39:06.560Z", "timestampMeaning": "response captured", "localTime": "2026-11-04 05:39:06 MST", "modelLabel": "Model: Opus 5.5 Medium", "account": "Claude Max, personal", "search": "Visible web search", "sourceFile": "review/demo-runs-2026-11-04/Claude-P2.json", "originalJsonSha256": "f4f591ef36b63c53e5354b321e08936f207e528e705601c36024508c5f36caa4", "transcriptSha256": "cdc71861beaaeedc026eecaec7094f7662e08cc700b0989b4d9bcef218471154", "promptSha256": "934d5322733232d72c85b57d9eba2fbd3b179f3baeeea4ff915e4a5c3bb39167", "finding": "Intent distinction recognized; footnote paragraph off.", "exhibit": "exhibits/CJ-CL-P2.html", "responseLineCount": 66 }, { "id": "CJ-CL-P3", "provider": "Claude", "run": "P3", "condition": "Structured A-prime", "timestamp": "2026-11-04T12:41:56.613Z", "timestampMeaning": "response captured", "localTime": "2026-11-04 05:41:56 MST", "modelLabel": "Model: Opus 5.5 Medium", "account": "Claude Max, personal", "search": "Visible web search", "sourceFile": "review/demo-runs-2026-11-04/Claude-P3.json", "originalJsonSha256": "756ec74286bbacdb9336c00c41b08ae03647907ea38c2071657f865769e8bba4", "transcriptSha256": "dd2ec7b9de13d3093c14f0db9e7cc3e7e618f4329810c988c181ad5e28e61453", "promptSha256": "934d5322733232d72c85b57d9eba2fbd3b179f3baeeea4ff915e4a5c3bb39167", "finding": "Intent distinction and footnote locator recognized.", "exhibit": "exhibits/CJ-CL-P3.html", "responseLineCount": 69 }, { "id": "CJ-CG-A1", "provider": "ChatGPT", "run": "A1", "condition": "Plain A", "timestamp": "2026-11-04T12:33:00.848Z", "timestampMeaning": "response captured", "localTime": "2026-11-04 05:33:00 MST", "modelLabel": "Thinking effort\nInstant", "account": "ChatGPT Pro, personal", "search": "All responses said web search unavailable", "sourceFile": "review/demo-runs-2026-11-04/ChatGPT-A1.json", "originalJsonSha256": "29118616f07f7d7c6fe31fca068f9080d98b78a61452079d312b5b4f980d1d37", "transcriptSha256": "da0e50945f78aad72c8364401853121d917cce625f72bf27b9a1ff85f89de506", "promptSha256": "6b74e7bea8c56c08450212e60d0da261d359a893431c7d04cedf4b837281e403", "finding": "General rule analysis; no verified Utah case.", "exhibit": "exhibits/CJ-CG-A1.html", "responseLineCount": 54 }, { "id": "CJ-CG-A2", "provider": "ChatGPT", "run": "A2", "condition": "Plain A", "timestamp": "2026-11-04T12:36:41.473Z", "timestampMeaning": "response captured", "localTime": "2026-11-04 05:36:41 MST", "modelLabel": "Thinking effort\nMedium", "account": "ChatGPT Pro, personal", "search": "All responses said web search unavailable", "sourceFile": "review/demo-runs-2026-11-04/ChatGPT-A2.json", "originalJsonSha256": "af343c294f89b830e794ba43287507b6a2d49eb8374457b161a3d2ebaa60c0bc", "transcriptSha256": "93522bc9606774876f0ac88c365eb67dfeb81aa235029eab246a9db4d56eeea3", "promptSha256": "6b74e7bea8c56c08450212e60d0da261d359a893431c7d04cedf4b837281e403", "finding": "Mata discussed; live search unavailable.", "exhibit": "exhibits/CJ-CG-A2.html", "responseLineCount": 92 }, { "id": "CJ-CG-A3", "provider": "ChatGPT", "run": "A3", "condition": "Plain A", "timestamp": "2026-11-04T12:40:11.798Z", "timestampMeaning": "response captured", "localTime": "2026-11-04 05:40:11 MST", "modelLabel": "Thinking effort\nMedium", "account": "ChatGPT Pro, personal", "search": "All responses said web search unavailable", "sourceFile": "review/demo-runs-2026-11-04/ChatGPT-A3.json", "originalJsonSha256": "53d74aa1ac4d84de807559b6ed2caf908d45807cf676a496d291c5725464f57d", "transcriptSha256": "2cf5e3e22bdc3feefe5cd77bfe90109a99ce83d409f9dddb8cff52f46cd28b19", "promptSha256": "6b74e7bea8c56c08450212e60d0da261d359a893431c7d04cedf4b837281e403", "finding": "Mata discussed; live search unavailable.", "exhibit": "exhibits/CJ-CG-A3.html", "responseLineCount": 119 }, { "id": "CJ-CG-P1", "provider": "ChatGPT", "run": "P1", "condition": "Structured A-prime", "timestamp": "2026-11-04T12:42:43.575Z", "timestampMeaning": "response captured", "localTime": "2026-11-04 05:42:43 MST", "modelLabel": "Thinking effort\nMedium", "account": "ChatGPT Pro, personal", "search": "All responses said web search unavailable", "sourceFile": "review/demo-runs-2026-11-04/ChatGPT-P1.json", "originalJsonSha256": "d6be8eaa087f5b5c33c1b34e43f0ffa5e45b7e526948764f39ae37ce4bc661bc", "transcriptSha256": "d0984b46e5ef96f756ec2572787a68fc945e5dcccf5385f659f6d50f1051d031", "promptSha256": "934d5322733232d72c85b57d9eba2fbd3b179f3baeeea4ff915e4a5c3bb39167", "finding": "Declines a verified Utah case/quote.", "exhibit": "exhibits/CJ-CG-P1.html", "responseLineCount": 36 }, { "id": "CJ-CG-P2", "provider": "ChatGPT", "run": "P2", "condition": "Structured A-prime", "timestamp": "2026-11-04T12:46:11.644Z", "timestampMeaning": "response captured", "localTime": "2026-11-04 05:46:11 MST", "modelLabel": "Thinking effort\nMedium", "account": "ChatGPT Pro, personal", "search": "All responses said web search unavailable", "sourceFile": "review/demo-runs-2026-11-04/ChatGPT-P2.json", "originalJsonSha256": "48ac092c6b101ec12674faf058d4892092adbacde3d509bf8979377d59f6966b", "transcriptSha256": "fc11bf1a9ef1eb5c64d45070775a141988606f868e3f88dc27c6bea6b71cc334", "promptSha256": "934d5322733232d72c85b57d9eba2fbd3b179f3baeeea4ff915e4a5c3bb39167", "finding": "Declines verified support for either categorical answer.", "exhibit": "exhibits/CJ-CG-P2.html", "responseLineCount": 92 }, { "id": "CJ-CG-P3", "provider": "ChatGPT", "run": "P3", "condition": "Structured A-prime", "timestamp": "2026-11-04T12:49:16.923Z", "timestampMeaning": "response captured", "localTime": "2026-11-04 05:49:16 MST", "modelLabel": "Thinking effort\nMedium", "account": "ChatGPT Pro, personal", "search": "All responses said web search unavailable", "sourceFile": "review/demo-runs-2026-11-04/ChatGPT-P3.json", "originalJsonSha256": "01beda57a1dba6169571fcfd178c97d55d1caa03902ae270410b0bd6135bf697", "transcriptSha256": "dbcd23c2fadb9a6bdb2ee63e16a44ce45f9dbe4136b4a5297c5dc9a8a82c8c9f", "promptSha256": "934d5322733232d72c85b57d9eba2fbd3b179f3baeeea4ff915e4a5c3bb39167", "finding": "Declines a verified Utah case/quote.", "exhibit": "exhibits/CJ-CG-P3.html", "responseLineCount": 83 }, { "id": "CJ-GM-A1", "provider": "Gemini", "run": "A1", "condition": "Plain A", "timestamp": "2026-11-04T12:33:30.811Z", "timestampMeaning": "response captured", "localTime": "2026-11-04 05:33:30 MST", "modelLabel": "Open mode picker, currently Flash High", "account": "Account type not separately established", "search": "Visible web search", "sourceFile": "review/demo-runs-2026-11-04/Gemini-A1.json", "originalJsonSha256": "fc234a8683aecc951f50a2bf739f89159fc9c6a6ae2d91c7d304dbe6fab179d8", "transcriptSha256": "09818eafac7aa500a576fb7a52cbb476a6bbcfb2c7667fc4856eed953066cb4d", "promptSha256": "6b74e7bea8c56c08450212e60d0da261d359a893431c7d04cedf4b837281e403", "finding": "Garner found; added disciplinary claim unsupported.", "exhibit": "exhibits/CJ-GM-A1.html", "responseLineCount": 62 }, { "id": "CJ-GM-A2", "provider": "Gemini", "run": "A2", "condition": "Plain A", "timestamp": "2026-11-04T12:37:27.369Z", "timestampMeaning": "response captured", "localTime": "2026-11-04 05:37:27 MST", "modelLabel": "Open mode picker, currently Flash High", "account": "Account type not separately established", "search": "Visible web search", "sourceFile": "review/demo-runs-2026-11-04/Gemini-A2.json", "originalJsonSha256": "ab7c72ced29a8697d0a2e094e54aef7efe3f7a24d1225f15cd7b3d48ccc3d65d", "transcriptSha256": "679d268fa13897647e49c924733bf48736d02a754b3b07a0fef5756087e0ef1f", "promptSha256": "6b74e7bea8c56c08450212e60d0da261d359a893431c7d04cedf4b837281e403", "finding": "Garner found; no exhaustive grading of all claims.", "exhibit": "exhibits/CJ-GM-A2.html", "responseLineCount": 49 }, { "id": "CJ-GM-A3", "provider": "Gemini", "run": "A3", "condition": "Plain A", "timestamp": "2026-11-04T12:42:04.732Z", "timestampMeaning": "response captured", "localTime": "2026-11-04 05:42:04 MST", "modelLabel": "Open mode picker, currently Flash High", "account": "Account type not separately established", "search": "Visible web search", "sourceFile": "review/demo-runs-2026-11-04/Gemini-A3.json", "originalJsonSha256": "343da8c3d77fe3befce678681d40927baa2924bfb990d01de56cab76631bc51a", "transcriptSha256": "ca6de58d071f5e08b6eaf717907cacf3ec34c2505367eff53c5ff9ad450c76ca", "promptSha256": "6b74e7bea8c56c08450212e60d0da261d359a893431c7d04cedf4b837281e403", "finding": "Garner found; broader assertions not fully graded.", "exhibit": "exhibits/CJ-GM-A3.html", "responseLineCount": 58 }, { "id": "CJ-GM-P1", "provider": "Gemini", "run": "P1", "condition": "Structured A-prime", "timestamp": "2026-11-04T12:44:32.725Z", "timestampMeaning": "response captured", "localTime": "2026-11-04 05:44:32 MST", "modelLabel": "Open mode picker, currently Flash High", "account": "Account type not separately established", "search": "Visible web search", "sourceFile": "review/demo-runs-2026-11-04/Gemini-P1.json", "originalJsonSha256": "3f524aee613d5cad3721c66e2553dda7464e3333dde7ac2657f23d811f6ae74d", "transcriptSha256": "f7c304ee159c7963be124a3b5c013034d833538b78a4f1a0f973e328ea5afe43", "promptSha256": "934d5322733232d72c85b57d9eba2fbd3b179f3baeeea4ff915e4a5c3bb39167", "finding": "Paragraph 8 paraphrase put in quotation marks.", "exhibit": "exhibits/CJ-GM-P1.html", "responseLineCount": 46 }, { "id": "CJ-GM-P2", "provider": "Gemini", "run": "P2", "condition": "Structured A-prime", "timestamp": "2026-11-04T12:46:25.234Z", "timestampMeaning": "response captured", "localTime": "2026-11-04 05:46:25 MST", "modelLabel": "Open mode picker, currently Flash High", "account": "Account type not separately established", "search": "Visible web search", "sourceFile": "review/demo-runs-2026-11-04/Gemini-P2.json", "originalJsonSha256": "3961ea213a433548aa3e7ba653e976bea4c388358209edf57bb0d75f1c4eb9bc", "transcriptSha256": "c44413b3846f8e9a4fb093a984b735b24cd476d19cf5b1b05aad462b8bfb5e3b", "promptSha256": "934d5322733232d72c85b57d9eba2fbd3b179f3baeeea4ff915e4a5c3bb39167", "finding": "Paragraph 7 source wrongly attributed to Mata.", "exhibit": "exhibits/CJ-GM-P2.html", "responseLineCount": 57 }, { "id": "CJ-GM-P3", "provider": "Gemini", "run": "P3", "condition": "Structured A-prime", "timestamp": "2026-11-04T12:50:25.013Z", "timestampMeaning": "response captured", "localTime": "2026-11-04 05:50:25 MST", "modelLabel": "Open mode picker, currently Flash High", "account": "Account type not separately established", "search": "Visible web search", "sourceFile": "review/demo-runs-2026-11-04/Gemini-P3.json", "originalJsonSha256": "5889ddfb170d2ffe7323f68b621b3e6cd637f719f57e3438522bcf49de59d21a", "transcriptSha256": "1afd137bd8bb9fdaa7727bce7d904cbaf2934dc35b8b92b73e83bcd9769851e3", "promptSha256": "934d5322733232d72c85b57d9eba2fbd3b179f3baeeea4ff915e4a5c3bb39167", "finding": "Same attribution error; paragraph 10 text stitched.", "exhibit": "exhibits/CJ-GM-P3.html", "responseLineCount": 51 }, { "id": "CJ-CP-A1", "provider": "Copilot", "run": "A1", "condition": "Plain A", "timestamp": "2026-11-04T12:38:19.243Z", "timestampMeaning": "response captured", "localTime": "2026-11-04 05:38:19 MST", "modelLabel": "Auto", "account": "Commercial data protection badge", "search": "Visible search/source results", "sourceFile": "review/demo-runs-2026-11-04/Copilot-A1.json", "originalJsonSha256": "a9dfbfa844ce9d57e80bb7005da8e003e120a7a252a8b3ba4c862588c47cbde5", "transcriptSha256": "daa1acef2620a199fb1ad597b564fdfda989a7c3bab19e3165114c0604f0d9a6", "promptSha256": "6b74e7bea8c56c08450212e60d0da261d359a893431c7d04cedf4b837281e403", "finding": "Garner found; central outcome described.", "exhibit": "exhibits/CJ-CP-A1.html", "responseLineCount": 37 }, { "id": "CJ-CP-A2", "provider": "Copilot", "run": "A2", "condition": "Plain A", "timestamp": "2026-11-04T12:40:27.631Z", "timestampMeaning": "response captured", "localTime": "2026-11-04 05:40:27 MST", "modelLabel": "Auto", "account": "Commercial data protection badge", "search": "Visible search/source results", "sourceFile": "review/demo-runs-2026-11-04/Copilot-A2.json", "originalJsonSha256": "226ffe9bf2e452f2158fc9f7dd3489ed54a65420c540809574b0513efb5e30f8", "transcriptSha256": "324890eaa7fa0ee0e6a7b550609ed06c9af4e64a16cd25f08de0c332396ef0c7", "promptSha256": "6b74e7bea8c56c08450212e60d0da261d359a893431c7d04cedf4b837281e403", "finding": "Garner found; same URL later used for A3.", "exhibit": "exhibits/CJ-CP-A2.html", "responseLineCount": 37 }, { "id": "CJ-CP-A3", "provider": "Copilot", "run": "A3", "condition": "Plain A", "timestamp": "2026-11-04T12:43:16.309Z", "timestampMeaning": "response captured", "localTime": "2026-11-04 05:43:16 MST", "modelLabel": "Auto", "account": "Commercial data protection badge", "search": "Visible search/source results", "sourceFile": "review/demo-runs-2026-11-04/Copilot-A3.json", "originalJsonSha256": "7c3224b2b9bd9271d00caa60427005085faee5b7949f55eefbebffeda7812665", "transcriptSha256": "ae6e20055c340582b858d6abe627ab814ffad435620e8bc19761a7b2bca513c8", "promptSha256": "6b74e7bea8c56c08450212e60d0da261d359a893431c7d04cedf4b837281e403", "finding": "Garner found; same URL as A2.", "exhibit": "exhibits/CJ-CP-A3.html", "responseLineCount": 39 }, { "id": "CJ-CP-P1", "provider": "Copilot", "run": "P1", "condition": "Structured A-prime", "timestamp": "2026-11-04T12:47:22.357Z", "timestampMeaning": "response captured", "localTime": "2026-11-04 05:47:22 MST", "modelLabel": "Auto", "account": "Commercial data protection badge", "search": "Visible search/source results", "sourceFile": "review/demo-runs-2026-11-04/Copilot-P1.json", "originalJsonSha256": "01dbf46d6476f2039798f966326fdad0cae7041ee26c6bbf175d99143687d8ea", "transcriptSha256": "d54ddb13d51c4eade59c5c26c043dd9723e8a1ff3e708686150398649f5019a6", "promptSha256": "934d5322733232d72c85b57d9eba2fbd3b179f3baeeea4ff915e4a5c3bb39167", "finding": "Central Garner quotations checked against opinion.", "exhibit": "exhibits/CJ-CP-P1.html", "responseLineCount": 75 }, { "id": "CJ-CP-P2", "provider": "Copilot", "run": "P2", "condition": "Structured A-prime", "timestamp": "2026-11-04T12:50:34.554Z", "timestampMeaning": "response captured", "localTime": "2026-11-04 05:50:34 MST", "modelLabel": "Auto", "account": "Commercial data protection badge", "search": "Visible search/source results", "sourceFile": "review/demo-runs-2026-11-04/Copilot-P2.json", "originalJsonSha256": "8eb8711c2e93e223787e84da330d8fb15e1330de85b69b2c8a9a877ba248364f", "transcriptSha256": "bdb5804c71c07c4d6b96503e48d83731f879d0d7f5d423da60d83170b9714e22", "promptSha256": "934d5322733232d72c85b57d9eba2fbd3b179f3baeeea4ff915e4a5c3bb39167", "finding": "Central Garner quotations checked against opinion.", "exhibit": "exhibits/CJ-CP-P2.html", "responseLineCount": 44 }, { "id": "CJ-CP-P3", "provider": "Copilot", "run": "P3", "condition": "Structured A-prime", "timestamp": "2026-11-04T12:55:10.431Z", "timestampMeaning": "response captured", "localTime": "2026-11-04 05:55:10 MST", "modelLabel": "Auto", "account": "Commercial data protection badge", "search": "Visible search/source results", "sourceFile": "review/demo-runs-2026-11-04/Copilot-P3.json", "originalJsonSha256": "90127b47c60d9b65384836fde5bc38e526e3297247b49c3920f7395a43353e1e", "transcriptSha256": "b9ca31a57ce3f749e6ab9bd78303a93e6d8bebe0dd3862339716a1edc5b214e2", "promptSha256": "934d5322733232d72c85b57d9eba2fbd3b179f3baeeea4ff915e4a5c3bb39167", "finding": "Central Garner quotations checked against opinion.", "exhibit": "exhibits/CJ-CP-P3.html", "responseLineCount": 72 }, { "id": "CJ-QW-A1", "provider": "Qwen", "run": "A1", "condition": "Plain A", "timestamp": "2026-11-04T12:49:48.787923+00:00", "timestampMeaning": "generation started", "localTime": "2026-11-04 05:49:48 MST", "modelLabel": "qwen3.8:latest", "account": "Local Ollama", "search": "No web search tools", "sourceFile": "review/demo-runs-2026-11-04/Qwen-A1.json", "originalJsonSha256": "3752ef05e395b10ed410af45b91a9e8fa011edb11f1251004f002879c4cba480", "transcriptSha256": "f2e0dc041524eff9450a1af0808a0b10ebdf770c897efaa75985bc7bd60f20ac", "promptSha256": "6b74e7bea8c56c08450212e60d0da261d359a893431c7d04cedf4b837281e403", "finding": "No named case; broad rule assertions unapproved.", "exhibit": "exhibits/CJ-QW-A1.html", "responseLineCount": 79, "elapsedSeconds": 299.69, "modelIdentity": "22130167c4c2;27.3B;Q4_K_M", "rawStdoutSha256": "fc65554c2c2ca36bb7628a10199ace4071c07ef93e8e63988aa29f71bdc1f0ab", "rawStderrSha256": "040c73fd7a58fbb47cef68f284422945bb618a15712ca87283a059b4f65ff703" }, { "id": "CJ-QW-A2", "provider": "Qwen", "run": "A2", "condition": "Plain A", "timestamp": "2026-11-04T12:54:48.477988+00:00", "timestampMeaning": "generation started", "localTime": "2026-11-04 05:54:48 MST", "modelLabel": "qwen3.8:latest", "account": "Local Ollama", "search": "No web search tools", "sourceFile": "review/demo-runs-2026-11-04/Qwen-A2.json", "originalJsonSha256": "93821704b1503af5ce05bf8b41864dac89da7f43954c3bdf22f6290398589b5c", "transcriptSha256": "9c4d7dc79a2b17e8f77f294cc1653f66e30412f42a0f0f2aab0ceb978cfd7ab7", "promptSha256": "6b74e7bea8c56c08450212e60d0da261d359a893431c7d04cedf4b837281e403", "finding": "No named case; broad rule assertions unapproved.", "exhibit": "exhibits/CJ-QW-A2.html", "responseLineCount": 50, "elapsedSeconds": 229.71, "modelIdentity": "22130167c4c2;27.3B;Q4_K_M", "rawStdoutSha256": "b8f490ea54e71040670eecc4d5fc97e97f3306c270fc83fe5298dcf5b38afd63", "rawStderrSha256": "8b67837449c2691ca19559ec4b10a7f49fb9ed1636f929b1e98d93495bd8d09a" }, { "id": "CJ-QW-A3", "provider": "Qwen", "run": "A3", "condition": "Plain A", "timestamp": "2026-11-04T12:58:38.189032+00:00", "timestampMeaning": "generation started", "localTime": "2026-11-04 05:58:38 MST", "modelLabel": "qwen3.8:latest", "account": "Local Ollama", "search": "No web search tools", "sourceFile": "review/demo-runs-2026-11-04/Qwen-A3.json", "originalJsonSha256": "dda607beb05af84d5b82d67a5473451c1c7e31e69549e368f3aff486b357f688", "transcriptSha256": "300c1082391ae8b3d40efec9e136eb80aba5079df1abb13c524ff2f683038dfb", "promptSha256": "6b74e7bea8c56c08450212e60d0da261d359a893431c7d04cedf4b837281e403", "finding": "Mata mentioned; general assertions unapproved.", "exhibit": "exhibits/CJ-QW-A3.html", "responseLineCount": 74, "elapsedSeconds": 295.5, "modelIdentity": "22130167c4c2;27.3B;Q4_K_M", "rawStdoutSha256": "5b7bc1cfb3cdca483f175dfd5eb2438c00e4e3aec93ffa93d0c4cf8282faac2d", "rawStderrSha256": "d0b147104cf7597c33414f00c96ba896f6e12f0367d2a8bdc54c4b9433600bd3" }, { "id": "CJ-QW-P1", "provider": "Qwen", "run": "P1", "condition": "Structured A-prime", "timestamp": "2026-11-04T13:03:33.674281+00:00", "timestampMeaning": "generation started", "localTime": "2026-11-04 06:03:33 MST", "modelLabel": "qwen3.8:latest", "account": "Local Ollama", "search": "No web search tools", "sourceFile": "review/demo-runs-2026-11-04/Qwen-P1.json", "originalJsonSha256": "c58a46323b11a31893baba85f3a5fc2f7f4d2667d54c373f765a86072d747e23", "transcriptSha256": "6fcd62c0587f1670124a3cf70a6d5b8d77fde5304e07ebb84e50473effdc3828", "promptSha256": "934d5322733232d72c85b57d9eba2fbd3b179f3baeeea4ff915e4a5c3bb39167", "finding": "No verified matching Utah case supplied.", "exhibit": "exhibits/CJ-QW-P1.html", "responseLineCount": 15, "elapsedSeconds": 123.05, "modelIdentity": "22130167c4c2;27.3B;Q4_K_M", "rawStdoutSha256": "fa7c980761c8e0199165924542b7de4b994b41eaa1d1415b187dd72ddea26870", "rawStderrSha256": "38921193395b27299d10074ad6add7369a9fed7904d3372d17b49a8b2b12dc8a" }, { "id": "CJ-QW-P2", "provider": "Qwen", "run": "P2", "condition": "Structured A-prime", "timestamp": "2026-11-04T13:05:36.722698+00:00", "timestampMeaning": "generation started", "localTime": "2026-11-04 06:05:36 MST", "modelLabel": "qwen3.8:latest", "account": "Local Ollama", "search": "No web search tools", "sourceFile": "review/demo-runs-2026-11-04/Qwen-P2.json", "originalJsonSha256": "edb8f03663f29914ee49d66eaecb2c67243e3f66d83ba9bf3d97e7ef3f062665", "transcriptSha256": "1e6a62c78d27d762946515e2834ea2d064831a25cde260320b79d8a33c9b7c52", "promptSha256": "934d5322733232d72c85b57d9eba2fbd3b179f3baeeea4ff915e4a5c3bb39167", "finding": "No verified Utah case; surrounding rules unapproved.", "exhibit": "exhibits/CJ-QW-P2.html", "responseLineCount": 46, "elapsedSeconds": 202.37, "modelIdentity": "22130167c4c2;27.3B;Q4_K_M", "rawStdoutSha256": "0b3e8c7fca365aa1d63a973fa20a5de0b6af1fb25e6174a761b6da766499efbc", "rawStderrSha256": "4fc1c20031107bc3738001419959cd2fc962392f6bfda1ad9b494594ae9cd56e" }, { "id": "CJ-QW-P3", "provider": "Qwen", "run": "P3", "condition": "Structured A-prime", "timestamp": "2026-11-04T13:08:59.089362+00:00", "timestampMeaning": "generation started", "localTime": "2026-11-04 06:08:59 MST", "modelLabel": "qwen3.8:latest", "account": "Local Ollama", "search": "No web search tools", "sourceFile": "review/demo-runs-2026-11-04/Qwen-P3.json", "originalJsonSha256": "54a7382e615b193513e442b8ca55412d6aedbb573177e1ab63e43bd4745ebe26", "transcriptSha256": "33d96423fc3cf031f883dd7787b8114706e864eb94356a8604400da77d77a775", "promptSha256": "934d5322733232d72c85b57d9eba2fbd3b179f3baeeea4ff915e4a5c3bb39167", "finding": "No verified Utah case; false Rule 8.4(b) quotation.", "exhibit": "exhibits/CJ-QW-P3.html", "responseLineCount": 27, "elapsedSeconds": 177.51, "modelIdentity": "22130167c4c2;27.3B;Q4_K_M", "rawStdoutSha256": "3a5b57e2bef371445e6c0f028618ee39162a793565e70603f0b169dca1a7e505", "rawStderrSha256": "8491f20dcc790cfc8811c51941fdc78796980e1b4e9d6bd9a37a216aff44067e" }, { "id": "CJ-DOC-01", "provider": "Claude", "run": "DOC1", "condition": "Source-bound document task, separate from paired sample", "timestamp": "2026-11-04T13:51:03.892Z", "timestampMeaning": "response captured", "modelLabel": "Model: Opus 5.5 Medium", "sourceFile": "review/document-task-2026-11-04/CJ-DOC-01.json", "originalJsonSha256": "cc72f9f8520a2851b524c887dd23988c5ca79aa343def9b9dc6a947c733258fd", "transcriptSha256": "b94638d1eb2d699166a05d88be4968fb17f746840e38a2c591747038077e5e11", "promptSha256": "dcd5d4a1a0f4a96782243842491c6e017cf74cff52b5303f232d4efca7dc14cf", "sourceSha256": "3f8424f651c79696938ed8fbc66a036424c0c6aa00b76d1a57c75951b82a9edb", "finding": "Three requested chronology rows and exact hearing quotation checked; petition date left not stated", "exhibit": "exhibits/CJ-DOC-01.html", "responseLineCount": 35, "pairedStudyMembership": false, "localTime": "2026-11-04 06:51:03 MST" } ], "examinations": [ { "id": "CJ-QA-01", "label": "Offline deck preflight, Version 1.3", "recordedAt": "2026-11-04T14:55:51.382941+00:00", "exitCode": 0, "scope": "Automated technical check; not legal acceptance or rehearsal", "stdout": "\nReady to present. 0 warning(s).\n" }, { "id": "CJ-QA-02", "label": "Deck script syntax, Version 1.3", "recordedAt": "2026-11-04T14:55:51.382941+00:00", "exitCode": 0, "scope": "Automated technical check; not legal acceptance or rehearsal", "stdout": "Node syntax check passed as part of preflight" }, { "id": "CJ-QA-03", "label": "Rendered deck and controls", "recordedAt": "2026-11-04T13:35:05.774463+00:00", "recordType": "Session observation or attributed prior review, compiled retrospectively", "detail": "Recorded November 4 session observation: 32 main slides passed checked safe-area geometry; all required images loaded; P/Escape, notes and blanking exercised and restored. Retained final slide PNGs support the visual review. Not a timed aloud rehearsal. Integrated appendix check: all 32 main slides and 11 new appendix slides passed checked safe-area geometry; all 11 new pages and the main citation placements were visually inspected. T opened the test index and Escape returned to the main demo slide. The report link, 30-exhibit schedule and a cited line anchor were opened in Comet; reader pages had no horizontal overflow." }, { "id": "CJ-QA-04", "label": "Cards and QR", "recordedAt": "2026-11-04T13:35:05.774463+00:00", "recordType": "Session observation or attributed prior review, compiled retrospectively", "detail": "Recorded November 4 inspection: single-page individual 288\u00d7378 pt, four-up US Letter 612\u00d7792 pt; rendered visually. Six script-decoded QR instances pointed to the landing URL. Sam separately reports QR tested. Completed printing and scan from paper were not confirmed." }, { "id": "CJ-QA-05", "label": "Settings captures", "recordedAt": "2026-11-04T13:35:05.774463+00:00", "recordType": "Session observation or attributed prior review, compiled retrospectively", "detail": "Recorded November 4: Claude Max and ChatGPT Pro training controls shown off; no settings changed. Required captures visually checked for account identifiers. No finding about retention, confidentiality or firm approval." }, { "id": "CJ-QA-06", "label": "Source chart and public links", "recordedAt": "2026-11-04T13:35:05.774463+00:00", "recordType": "Session observation or attributed prior review, compiled retrospectively", "detail": "Recorded November 4: official Z.ai chart matched supplied PNG byte for byte, not independent benchmark reproduction. Landing HTTP 200/noindex. Booking HTTP 200 and intended title/metadata, not a booking or full availability-flow test." }, { "id": "CJ-REV-01", "label": "Independent deck review", "recordedAt": "2026-11-04T13:35:05.774463+00:00", "recordType": "Session observation or attributed prior review, compiled retrospectively", "detail": "Codex evaluation dated November 3, retained in review/codex-evaluation-2026-11-03.md. Addresses alignment, factual support, audience, timing and rendering limitations; later corrections and day-of checks are recorded separately." }, { "id": "CJ-REV-02", "label": "Earlier Perplexity review reported by Sam", "recordedAt": "2026-11-04T13:35:05.774463+00:00", "recordType": "Session observation or attributed prior review, compiled retrospectively", "detail": "Separate earlier review: existing process-slide record reports five contradiction searches, 107 returned sources and at least 13 unrelated matches. Original query/response exports are not in this 30-run inventory; this appendix does not reconstruct or independently recertify those counts." }, { "id": "CJ-ACCESS-PP", "label": "Perplexity access outcome", "recordedAt": "2026-11-04T13:35:05.774463+00:00", "recordType": "Session observation or attributed prior review, compiled retrospectively", "detail": "For the paired test: zero runs. Sam confirmed sharing; the controller did not expose the requested tab. One navigation returned Page.navigate: Not allowed. This is an access outcome, not a model failure or substantive response." }, { "id": "CJ-QA-07", "label": "Source-bound chronology verification", "recordedAt": "2026-11-04T13:54:49.771483+00:00", "trial": "CJ-DOC-01", "sourceSha256": "3f8424f651c79696938ed8fbc66a036424c0c6aa00b76d1a57c75951b82a9edb", "responseJsonSha256": "cc72f9f8520a2851b524c887dd23988c5ca79aa343def9b9dc6a947c733258fd", "result": "Three requested rows and hearing quotation checked against saved opinion", "quote": "On April 22, 2025, Petitioner\u2019s counsel appeared at the OSC hearing along with Petitioner.", "quoteExactAfterPdfWhitespaceNormalization": true, "petitionDateAbsenceReview": "Agent read supplied full opinion; paragraph 2 reports timely filing without a calendar date. No calendar date for that filing was found.", "promptProvenance": "Canonical filled prompt retained. Rendered user-message innerText omits ordered footnote list markers 1\u20136 because of HTML list rendering; this is recorded, not treated as a source or prompt replacement.", "scope": "Single source-bound extraction example; not comparative evidence of time savings or general accuracy" }, { "id": "CJ-QA-08", "label": "Legal Graph citation retrieval and source comparison", "recordedAt": "2026-11-04T14:18:02.696479+00:00", "recordType": "Bounded direct public-source inspection", "detail": "Published links, review/admission metadata, topic relationships, coverage passage and supplied illustrations checked. Mata extracted PDF text matches all 43 pages. Direct Garner mirror HTTP 403 retained; alternate web-tool text accessible. Not a citator clearance, legal acceptance, admission renewal or new model trial.", "manifest": "graph-sources/manifest.json", "sourceManifestSha256": "faec7d86f7ccbcb456692d5714c0375f8cf454e784fee584302ba36223028951" }, { "id": "CJ-QA-09", "label": "Version 1.2 final presentation and citation integrity checks", "recordedAt": "2026-11-04T14:29:21.799318+00:00", "recordType": "Command checks plus Comet UI observations", "observations": { "preflight": { "exitCode": 0, "warnings": "Three pre-existing optional captures absent: A-prime variant and original unrun Demo C images." }, "originalModelRecords": "31 original JSON and exact transcript hashes verified; run inventory unchanged from v1.1.", "sourceHashes": "11 successfully retained public-source snapshots and two supplied image hashes verified. One direct Garner request returned 403; alternate web-tool access documented.", "localLinks": "All linked local files/fragments in deck, memorandum and graph source schedule pass, excluding two declared optional unrun Demo C image gaps.", "layout": "Comet, 1458\u00d7813 viewport: 52 populated slides checked, comprising 32 main and 20 appendix. Safe-area geometry and image loading pass. Three old unrun appendix demo/exercise pages excluded.", "visualReview": "New evidence map, supplied image 2 overview, Own it citation, conclusions citation, source schedule and corrected process appendix visually inspected. Long source metadata wraps without horizontal overflow.", "controls": "T opens the updated testing appendix; Escape returns to Own it. Shared deck left on evidence map with notes off.", "existingRepair": "Process appendix overflow found by broader geometry pass; image height and list margins tightened, text and font size unchanged.", "publicTransform": "Notes/name stripping and new appendix IDs checked in memory only; no public build or publication.", "limits": "Technical/source-consistency checks do not establish legal acceptance, current treatment, source admission, human verification renewal, event timing or paper QR acceptance." }, "screenshots": [ { "file": "review/legal-graph-map-2026-11-04.png", "sha256": "f01f875dc6ed1db4ed744a225e7d5d168e31e5873ca6c29eecfb4fca9f97c0b7" }, { "file": "review/legal-graph-overview-2026-11-04.png", "sha256": "1baa9f04d71957df2dcc71c245c4105e38c8df429c366e87c81372516729f6c3" }, { "file": "review/own-it-graph-citation-2026-11-04.png", "sha256": "6ca63219a5b5bbc1551847ac64283a7d8a43409ed59ed41f065365778ff19afa" }, { "file": "review/conclusions-graph-citation-2026-11-04.png", "sha256": "16716cca5b58f6fed7466483e9b91c0807aeb4c87c01f04d4c8852f14d2f3960" }, { "file": "review/process-fit-2026-11-04.png", "sha256": "3300f14537f82a097a97d5608dc586706e3c96fb6770d9fd982c4bcae2dea860" }, { "file": "review/graph-source-schedule-2026-11-04.png", "sha256": "5d2ad6ab19aac183f2723ca0e8f0f736aac38522aedfab50fe3daa30a7a09966" } ], "deckSha256": "08e3cfd2e4a65b392cd1d91275bd383b2a79ca8d3839ec5f6d91a2940504b2e8", "sourceManifestSha256": "faec7d86f7ccbcb456692d5714c0375f8cf454e784fee584302ba36223028951" }, { "id": "CJ-QA-10", "label": "Public-source case-treatment review", "recordedAt": "2026-11-04T14:47:03.163015+00:00", "recordType": "Court-source review and public citation/history search", "review": "current-treatment/review.json", "sources": "current-treatment/sources.json", "reviewSha256": "af9fefe7f7e45b3388bafbe10067da9e65315aaa7722740c1150c2a09d1364d0", "detail": "Public-source review complete for the presentation scope. No adverse disposition located that changes the narrow historical propositions used. This is not a commercial citator clearance or a representation that every appeal, rehearing, mandate, compliance filing or sealed docket event was retrieved." }, { "id": "CJ-QA-11", "label": "Version 1.3 all-slide functional completeness audit", "recordedAt": "2026-11-04T14:55:51.382941+00:00", "recordType": "Content review, Comet native layout and control checks, visual contact sheets and offline checks", "status": "PASS", "mainSlides": 32, "appendixSlides": 22, "allSlides": 54, "excludedSlides": [], "removedPlaceholders": [ "demo-c", "demo-c-saved" ], "deckSha256": "8d3df455be878b547d976abf40f19fbb0cd073ec9aa21d51dd39a5e23aa26cd4", "observations": { "content": "Every remaining slide body and notes reviewed. Saved demos populated; historical Mata exercise and future untested H1 distinguished. No visible todo/missing markers or empty demo prompts.", "nativeLayout": "Every one of 54 slides checked at its native 1600 by 900 stage. Required images loaded, bottom content within safe area, no slide overflow and no unresolved internal slide anchors.", "visual": "All 54 slides visually inspected in six contact sheets, nine slides each. New case-treatment slide also inspected full size. Contact sheets are temporary DOM clones for overview; native measurements use original slides. Overlay removed.", "controls": "Home/End, arrows, P/S/T, Escape, notes and blanking passed. Count input events updated closing outputs and all four original inputs/storage were restored. Actual browser Home key returned to title. One initial synthetic key test targeted document and produced a harness error; corrected bubbling body events passed without changing deck code.", "historicalExercise": "All four offline Mata steps, next/previous and arrow keys, image loading, horizontal fit and return-to-deck link passed.", "caseReader": "Eight case sections, scope and access limits present. No horizontal overflow or broken images. Return to deck passed.", "preflight": { "exitCode": 0, "warnings": 0, "stdout": "\nReady to present. 0 warning(s).\n" }, "modelEvidence": "31 original model JSON and exact transcript hashes verified earlier in this final pass; unchanged from v1.2.", "sourceEvidence": "18 successful retained current-treatment court/index snapshots hash-verified. Access failures remain recorded, not represented as retrieved sources.", "limits": "Functional completion does not certify commercial citator clearance, exhaustive docket coverage, legal acceptance, renewed native-corpus admission, timed rehearsal, paper QR acceptance or publication.", "localLinks": { "authoredHtmlFiles": 36, "localReferencesChecked": 2115, "failures": [] } }, "perSlideAudit": "review/final-all-slide-audit-2026-11-04.json", "perSlideAuditSha256": "00d861f88a6a7a4c4a7131e805a3994f6b4f4c7e873c1d0716262412bfef5e30", "screenshots": [ { "file": "review/final-all-slides-01-2026-11-04.png", "sha256": "f856d22b493df467b9caa24dcd09ae187827560d093851b28d07ad85f35be421", "slides": "1-9" }, { "file": "review/final-all-slides-02-2026-11-04.png", "sha256": "746ba53dfab93086cb0692c826e28e244fe22d5024c9e4c9c5ab6838ae0b0721", "slides": "10-18" }, { "file": "review/final-all-slides-03-2026-11-04.png", "sha256": "8c68b3e2ad0f7669ccddda11e5995baae9744fc010ae19cf804a9e64cb089fac", "slides": "19-27" }, { "file": "review/final-all-slides-04-2026-11-04.png", "sha256": "4f4c5b6a4ef9c407c2f5e9de954fef9bb7ce0edd851c23699e5dcb81b874e8e2", "slides": "28-36" }, { "file": "review/final-all-slides-05-2026-11-04.png", "sha256": "d80f69b42b1804f6788b5a59e4dde4ec289a858a943fbb99c73bab070b9827bf", "slides": "37-45" }, { "file": "review/final-all-slides-06-2026-11-04.png", "sha256": "1329aeca65b646f9b6e30944ec456a06969475a248d7eb5a29af1f055e5fba47", "slides": "46-54" } ] } ], "materials": [ { "id": "CJ-SRC-01", "label": "Garner v. Kadince, Inc., 2025 UT App 80, \u00b6\u00b65, 7\u201316 and n.4", "url": "https://law.justia.com/cases/utah/court-of-appeals-published/2025/20250188-ca.html", "savedFile": "sources/garner-v-kadince-2025-ut-app-80.pdf", "sha256": "3f8424f651c79696938ed8fbc66a036424c0c6aa00b76d1a57c75951b82a9edb" }, { "id": "CJ-SRC-02", "label": "Mata v. Avianca, ECF 54, June 22, 2023", "url": "https://courtlistener.com/docket/63107798/", "savedFile": "sources/mata-sanctions-order-2023-06-22.pdf", "sha256": "68c7e61823d8dd1540e1b8ce61ce3da99d601f032e4ea22825eba224a78c4d32" }, { "id": "CJ-SRC-03", "label": "Lacey v. State Farm General Insurance Co., ECF 119, special-master order, signed May 5/filed May 6, 2025", "url": "https://toplaw.news/litigationworld/d/2025-05-15-LitigationWorld-Order.pdf", "savedFile": "review/demo-runs-2026-11-04/lacey-ecf-119-2025-05-06.pdf", "sha256": "8d47a790230349c9e8dfa2439279a6c101ed042f95be3b80435bcbedd24f4eac" }, { "id": "CJ-SRC-04", "label": "Prisbrey v. Prisbrey, 2026 UT App 39, 588 P.3d 329, n.6", "url": "https://websitedc.s3.amazonaws.com/documents/Prisbrey_v_Prisbrey_USA_19_March_2026.pdf", "savedFile": "review/demo-runs-2026-11-04/prisbrey-2026-ut-app-39.pdf", "sha256": "7cff490e2defc381cc0f78bd68213a22f17e49650c521c5e2f31cf69c362135f", "currentSource": "current-treatment/CJ-CT-12.pdf", "currentSourceSha256": "a1703ee58c211786f2f7897ef81063197edf2048937336988e3f3e85dc2b45cd" }, { "id": "CJ-SRC-05", "label": "Utah Courts, Rule 3-8.4, effective November 1, 2026; paragraph (b)", "url": "https://legacy.utcourts.gov/rules/view.php?rule=3-8.4/1000&type=scrp", "savedFile": null, "sha256": null }, { "id": "CJ-REC-01", "label": "Day-of verification and synthesis", "sha256AtCompilation": "dea07263e93b81028265c02fc6e4339cdb7753d617fa308d8c60b2db717580c6", "localRecordOnly": true, "retainedSnapshot": "review/test-record-materials-2026-11-04/CJ-REC-01.md" }, { "id": "CJ-REC-02", "label": "Independent deck evaluation", "sha256AtCompilation": "a98b9da1bf16dd91f1976ffe7eab95265e8381b60603bd7936f1e22384a21811", "localRecordOnly": true, "retainedSnapshot": "review/test-record-materials-2026-11-04/CJ-REC-02.md" }, { "id": "CJ-REC-03", "label": "Claims register", "sha256AtCompilation": "d54ef9b501bbdf7998aba526993c5632d6c60bb2645951ce8f4c1f358b487351", "localRecordOnly": true, "retainedSnapshot": "review/test-record-materials-2026-11-04/CJ-REC-03.md" } ], "finalizedAt": "2026-11-04T14:55:51.382941+00:00", "deckMainSlideCount": 32, "deckAppendixSlideCount": 22, "newTestingAppendixSlideCount": 18, "validation": { "responseOriginalHashesAndTranscriptBytes": "31 verified", "localLinksAndFragmentAnchors": "Passed for all authored reader pages and all referenced local files/fragments, without slide exclusions; detailed count in CJ-QA-11.", "renderedSafeAreas": "All 54 slides: 32 main and 22 appendix; passed without exclusions.", "TAndEscape": "passed", "publicTransform": "In-memory notes/name stripping and new appendix IDs passed; no public build", "visualReview": "All 54 remaining slides reviewed in six contact sheets; native geometry independently checked.", "modelOutputs": "31 original response hashes and exact reader-transcript hashes verified; original paired 30 unchanged", "legalGraphAddendum": "Passed bounded source checks, snapshot/image hashes, exact locators and final layout verification; see CJ-QA-08/09", "finalAllSlideAudit": "PASS; checks/CJ-QA-11.json; no excluded or unfinished slides" }, "amendedAt": "2026-11-04T14:47:03.163015+00:00", "pairedModelResponseCount": 30, "documentTaskResponseCount": 1, "priorVersion": { "version": "1.2", "retainedLocally": "review/test-record-versions-2026-11-04/", "recordSha256": "9cd9e7688bbfddfb81208be04a6365a91a35c6281c2170a95a2478ef0a2b27ab", "memorandumSha256": "a056bd849933f414d95acf92580806e91c99562e29f9497f839c04d7e1fdc859" }, "hypothesis": { "id": "H1", "status": "Not comparatively tested", "claim": "For matched legal-analysis tasks under fixed system conditions, evidence-oriented instructions and source-supplied analysis will reduce unsupported material propositions and human verification burden relative to an ordinary request, while preserving material qualifications.", "documentTaskImplication": "CJ-DOC-01 demonstrates feasibility on one extraction task; it does not test the comparative hypothesis." }, "priorVersions": [ { "version": "1.0", "retainedLocally": "review/test-record-versions-2026-11-04/", "recordSha256": "591ce87ca111cbad1ff4b50bece6d189e1ff0b1b5a1b36e192f10442a465e55e", "memorandumSha256": "034ebd76633470a7bf4494920510ec7be86f84983e7b7fe3a4289815543009b9" }, { "version": "1.1", "retainedLocally": "review/test-record-versions-2026-11-04/", "recordSha256": "ceb3761604e208fd40d177a4278b292c7ec885c8bf1d5d7b6805749b846e94b3", "memorandumSha256": "cd2153a2cb7c649af2814bfe9904a07b7efb5d080368e1bb9643ce16fd47fa3c" } ], "graphCitationAddendum": { "section": 11, "paragraphs": "29\u201334", "sourceSchedule": "graph-sources/index.html", "manifest": "graph-sources/manifest.json", "sourceManifestSha256": "faec7d86f7ccbcb456692d5714c0375f8cf454e784fee584302ba36223028951", "retrievalDate": "2026-11-04", "maintainerDisclosure": "Sam Rogers, PAICE.work PBC", "illustrationSelected": "CJ-LG-IMG-02", "limits": [ "Recorded review dates and admission statuses unchanged; retrieval time is not a human verification date.", "The graph retrieval was not a treatment review. The subsequent bounded public-source treatment review is separately recorded in section 12, with its coverage limits.", "Sources served now can retain earlier generated_at or review dates.", "Hashes identify retained bytes; they do not prove source authenticity or legal accuracy.", "Supplied screenshots have an unknown capture time and are explanatory illustrations." ], "sourceScheduleSha256": "194e6ce7e2e277f96b262d62ecd69f12d7bb6709274d5e571dd8d540cb77d5e0", "finalCheck": "checks/CJ-QA-09.json" }, "caseTreatmentReview": { "asOf": "2026-11-04", "status": "Complete within stated public-source scope", "record": "current-treatment/review.json", "reviewSha256": "af9fefe7f7e45b3388bafbe10067da9e65315aaa7722740c1150c2a09d1364d0", "noCommercialCitatorClearance": true } }