{
  "recordId": "CJ-TR-20261104",
  "addendum": "Legal Graph citation research",
  "date": "2026-11-04",
  "method": "Bounded direct public retrieval, field inspection and source comparison; no paid research calls, legal citator review, human admission renewal or graph-owner edits",
  "sources": [
    {
      "id": "CJ-LG-01",
      "publisher": "PAICE.work PBC",
      "title": "AI Incident Law, Mata proceeding",
      "url": "https://aiincidentlaw.org/proceeding/aiel-2023-002-proceeding.json",
      "retrievedAt": "2026-11-04T14:14:56.731157+00:00",
      "role": "Curated reference; not independent legal authority",
      "httpStatus": 200,
      "resolvedUrl": "https://aiincidentlaw.org/proceeding/aiel-2023-002-proceeding.json",
      "contentType": "application/json; charset=utf-8",
      "etag": "\"6aeac42b-94e\"",
      "lastModifiedHeader": "Wed, 04 Nov 2026 05:35:39 GMT",
      "snapshot": "CJ-LG-01.json",
      "sha256": "2101aee913a510c3fbdb499fc3e0fca0ba380bc1ea32fb94845c6b6e7c010f58",
      "bytes": 2382,
      "recordMetadata": {
        "@id": "https://aiincidentlaw.org/proceeding/aiel-2023-002-proceeding.json",
        "id": "aiel-2023-002-proceeding",
        "verified": "2026-09-01",
        "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed",
        "projection_basis": "curated-legal-graph",
        "source": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.nysd.575368/gov.uscourts.nysd.575368.54.0_8.pdf",
        "hasDetermination": [
          "https://aiincidentlaw.org/determination/aiel-2023-002-determination.json"
        ]
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "CJ-LG-02",
      "publisher": "PAICE.work PBC",
      "title": "AI Incident Law, Mata determination",
      "url": "https://aiincidentlaw.org/determination/aiel-2023-002-determination.json",
      "retrievedAt": "2026-11-04T14:14:56.815833+00:00",
      "role": "Curated reference; not independent legal authority",
      "httpStatus": 200,
      "resolvedUrl": "https://aiincidentlaw.org/determination/aiel-2023-002-determination.json",
      "contentType": "application/json; charset=utf-8",
      "etag": "\"6aeac42c-a94\"",
      "lastModifiedHeader": "Wed, 04 Nov 2026 05:35:40 GMT",
      "snapshot": "CJ-LG-02.json",
      "sha256": "41c84dd56fd31aa81e4ef2f89db7df3d2aa20a7061ea89acbc8dfd59a1d7ac1f",
      "bytes": 2708,
      "recordMetadata": {
        "@id": "https://aiincidentlaw.org/determination/aiel-2023-002-determination.json",
        "id": "aiel-2023-002-determination",
        "verified": "2026-09-01",
        "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed",
        "projection_basis": "curated-legal-graph",
        "source": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.nysd.575368/gov.uscourts.nysd.575368.54.0_8.pdf",
        "anchors": [
          "https://everyailaw.com/obligation-category/human-oversight.json"
        ]
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "CJ-LG-03",
      "publisher": "PAICE.work PBC",
      "title": "EveryAILaw, Human Oversight category export",
      "url": "https://everyailaw.com/obligation-category/human-oversight.json",
      "retrievedAt": "2026-11-04T14:14:56.887876+00:00",
      "role": "Editorial category; no case-specific applicability conclusion",
      "httpStatus": 200,
      "resolvedUrl": "https://everyailaw.com/obligation-category/human-oversight.json",
      "contentType": "application/json; charset=utf-8",
      "etag": "\"6aeaec1f-479\"",
      "lastModifiedHeader": "Wed, 04 Nov 2026 08:26:07 GMT",
      "snapshot": "CJ-LG-03.json",
      "sha256": "cfcf59399858217b1d5b7cc4ba24f327a8973751de346a09cf3c06e4fe68c834",
      "bytes": 1145,
      "recordMetadata": {
        "@id": "https://everyailaw.com/obligation-category/human-oversight.json",
        "admission_status": "legacy-unreviewed",
        "source_review_unresolved": null,
        "projection_basis": "native-record-projection"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "CJ-LG-04",
      "publisher": "PAICE.work PBC",
      "title": "EveryAILaw, Human Oversight",
      "url": "https://everyailaw.com/obligation/human-oversight/",
      "retrievedAt": "2026-11-04T14:14:56.956862+00:00",
      "role": "Editorial category and explanatory framework",
      "httpStatus": 200,
      "resolvedUrl": "https://everyailaw.com/obligation/human-oversight/",
      "contentType": "text/html; charset=utf-8",
      "etag": "\"6aeaec1f-7aca\"",
      "lastModifiedHeader": "Wed, 04 Nov 2026 08:26:07 GMT",
      "snapshot": "CJ-LG-04.html.txt",
      "sha256": "5279b53d60e70e351bec7c8f1309ae1450b09b7f91346ca77458680710399e1a",
      "bytes": 31434
    },
    {
      "id": "CJ-LG-05",
      "publisher": "PAICE.work PBC",
      "title": "PubLedge, Utah coverage review",
      "url": "https://publedge.org/us/utah/#coverage-review",
      "retrievedAt": "2026-11-04T14:14:57.123875+00:00",
      "role": "Dated coverage statement, not fresh source-document or clause review",
      "httpStatus": 200,
      "resolvedUrl": "https://publedge.org/us/utah/#coverage-review",
      "contentType": "text/html; charset=utf-8",
      "etag": "\"6aeaddf8-5e60\"",
      "lastModifiedHeader": "Wed, 04 Nov 2026 07:25:44 GMT",
      "snapshot": "CJ-LG-05.html.txt",
      "sha256": "7dce11d8612ce1a7b26d343fdb49bdb27d5ac48a59e5cc161b750118b07d84de",
      "bytes": 24160,
      "coverageStatement": "Utah coverage review Coverage comparison date: Oct 14, 2026 . This compares the official public index with PubLedge's inventory; it is not a new legal verification of each agreement. Source-document review and clause-level mapping remain separate steps. Known records not yet indexed in this reference instance: Expect Fitness August AI / August Labs, Inc. Nolla Health / Magic Health entities University of Utah Health master agreement Intermountain Health master agreement A master agreement alone does not authorize a pilot. Unindexed means missing from this instance, not unissued by OAIP. SHA-256 checks compare canonical source bytes with the current unsigned manifest. They do not prove agency issuance, source authenticity, publication time, completeness, or legal accuracy. How to verify and what the check proves . Propose a correction PubLedge's Utah reference instance is a third-party public mirror, not an OAIP product. If you are OAIP staff, a participant, or an outside reviewer who has spotted an inaccuracy, please open a correction issue on GitHub or email hello@paice.work . Every page's frontmatter is versioned in the public repo ; corrections land as commits with a clear audit trail. Related Utah AI statutes (not in this registry) This reference instance indexes selected sta"
    },
    {
      "id": "CJ-LG-06",
      "publisher": "PAICE.work PBC",
      "title": "Obligation-First, shared schema overview",
      "url": "https://obligationfirst.org/",
      "retrievedAt": "2026-11-04T14:14:57.199539+00:00",
      "role": "Schema methodology, not substantive law",
      "httpStatus": 200,
      "resolvedUrl": "https://obligationfirst.org/",
      "contentType": "text/html; charset=utf-8",
      "etag": "\"6ae03d66-b525\"",
      "lastModifiedHeader": "Tue, 27 Oct 2026 05:57:58 GMT",
      "snapshot": "CJ-LG-06.html.txt",
      "sha256": "58fd0bd22c705aebcaae2732d2e99bf98cdb4c22af37bf66704a197c9c15f4b5",
      "bytes": 46373
    },
    {
      "id": "CJ-LG-07",
      "publisher": "PAICE.work PBC",
      "title": "AI Incident Law, How this fits in the legal graph",
      "url": "https://aiincidentlaw.org/docs/legal-graph.html",
      "retrievedAt": "2026-11-04T14:14:57.418105+00:00",
      "role": "Publisher explanation of component roles",
      "httpStatus": 200,
      "resolvedUrl": "https://aiincidentlaw.org/docs/legal-graph.html",
      "contentType": "text/html; charset=utf-8",
      "etag": "\"6aeac42b-4b09\"",
      "lastModifiedHeader": "Wed, 04 Nov 2026 05:35:39 GMT",
      "snapshot": "CJ-LG-07.html.txt",
      "sha256": "a82ca949446a06e17e613ab6991fb6906df5bdf042dd8beffb34e6aba4f2aece",
      "bytes": 19209
    },
    {
      "id": "CJ-LG-08",
      "publisher": "PAICE.work PBC",
      "title": "AI Incident Law, published native corpus",
      "url": "https://aiincidentlaw.org/data/data.json",
      "retrievedAt": "2026-11-04T14:14:57.501153+00:00",
      "role": "Published snapshot only; absence is not absence of a case",
      "httpStatus": 200,
      "resolvedUrl": "https://aiincidentlaw.org/data/data.json",
      "contentType": "application/json; charset=utf-8",
      "etag": "\"6aeac42b-4dff5\"",
      "lastModifiedHeader": "Wed, 04 Nov 2026 05:35:39 GMT",
      "snapshot": "CJ-LG-08.json",
      "sha256": "28b84631caad8ae1d69267cb13ec30c71ca69d9d9c5bf8cfb421cf65ef2c3743",
      "bytes": 319477,
      "recordMetadata": {
        "generated_at": "2026-09-22"
      },
      "garnerNameMatches": []
    },
    {
      "id": "CJ-LG-09",
      "publisher": "PAICE.work PBC",
      "title": "PAICE.work PBC, project and connection overview",
      "url": "https://paice.foundation/",
      "retrievedAt": "2026-11-04T14:14:57.642022+00:00",
      "role": "Publisher overview; supplied images are illustrations",
      "httpStatus": 200,
      "resolvedUrl": "https://paice.foundation/",
      "contentType": "text/html; charset=utf-8",
      "etag": "\"6aeae8de-95b7\"",
      "lastModifiedHeader": "Wed, 04 Nov 2026 08:12:14 GMT",
      "snapshot": "CJ-LG-09.html.txt",
      "sha256": "e901091b78b980c37fb69bb5ea3e9cc214c46db4c3603fd4b4c7415d0bff4898",
      "bytes": 38327,
      "imageOverviewTextPresent": false
    },
    {
      "id": "CJ-LG-10",
      "publisher": "Court-authored document via named mirror",
      "title": "Mata, ECF 54, court-authored sanctions opinion via CourtListener",
      "url": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.nysd.575368/gov.uscourts.nysd.575368.54.0_8.pdf",
      "retrievedAt": "2026-11-04T14:14:57.979396+00:00",
      "role": "Primary court document, mirrored; no current-treatment certification",
      "httpStatus": 200,
      "resolvedUrl": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.nysd.575368/gov.uscourts.nysd.575368.54.0_8.pdf",
      "contentType": "application/pdf",
      "etag": "\"2e21ef02c4e1ac8cf982ac4a51489b33\"",
      "lastModifiedHeader": "Wed, 10 Jan 2024 18:46:27 GMT",
      "snapshot": "CJ-LG-10.pdf",
      "sha256": "68c7e61823d8dd1540e1b8ce61ce3da99d601f032e4ea22825eba224a78c4d32",
      "bytes": 2341028
    },
    {
      "id": "CJ-LG-11",
      "publisher": "Court-authored document via named mirror",
      "title": "Garner, 2025 UT App 80, court-authored opinion via Justia",
      "url": "https://law.justia.com/cases/utah/court-of-appeals-published/2025/20250188-ca.html",
      "retrievedAt": "2026-11-04T14:14:58.434476+00:00",
      "role": "Primary court opinion text, mirrored; no current-treatment certification",
      "error": "HTTPError: HTTP Error 403: Forbidden",
      "httpStatus": 403,
      "alternateAccess": "Court-authored opinion text retrieved using web research tool on 2026-11-04; direct HTTP blocked. No direct-fetch snapshot retained; existing CJ-SRC-01 PDF remains retained.",
      "retryAttempted": false
    },
    {
      "id": "CJ-LG-IMG-01",
      "title": "Sam-supplied PAICE Legal Graph image 1",
      "suppliedDate": "2026-11-04",
      "captureDate": "unknown",
      "path": "../../img/PAICE-LegalGraph1.png",
      "sha256": "1be89e839acb477c59fef044ea3e96389bb572effff2bc1c893513e7f415d3e1",
      "bytes": 1377967,
      "role": "Explanatory illustration; not independent evidence of deployed behavior",
      "selectedForDeck": false
    },
    {
      "id": "CJ-LG-IMG-02",
      "title": "Sam-supplied PAICE Legal Graph image 2",
      "suppliedDate": "2026-11-04",
      "captureDate": "unknown",
      "path": "../../img/PAICE-LegalGraph2.png",
      "sha256": "8b4c78a840fca09c9fa828e7565e6c74eac50e704aae7224b6a24edd1a6610bc",
      "bytes": 263592,
      "role": "Explanatory illustration; not independent evidence of deployed behavior",
      "selectedForDeck": true
    },
    {
      "id": "CJ-LG-12",
      "publisher": "PAICE.work PBC",
      "title": "PAICE Legal Graph, project roles and connections",
      "url": "https://paice.foundation/work/legal-graph/",
      "retrievedAt": "2026-11-04T14:15:43.064717+00:00",
      "httpStatus": 200,
      "snapshot": "CJ-LG-12.html.txt",
      "sha256": "b4a0d4fd570c55a3dd8a04d6e774ca04848687e6c4da67c5223c1f45de8b5506",
      "bytes": 9798,
      "role": "Publisher architecture explanation; not independent legal evidence",
      "imageOverviewTextPresent": true
    }
  ],
  "scopeLimits": [
    "Recorded review dates and admission statuses unchanged; retrieval time is not a human verification date.",
    "Bounded public lookup is not an exhaustive search, citator or subsequent-treatment review.",
    "Sources served now can retain earlier generated_at or review dates.",
    "Hashes identify retained bytes; they do not prove source authenticity or legal accuracy.",
    "Supplied screenshots have an unknown capture time and are explanatory illustrations."
  ],
  "sourceChecks": {
    "mataPdfTextComparison": {
      "method": "pdftotext -layout on the previously retained source and newly retrieved graph-linked PDF",
      "all43PagesTextIdentical": true,
      "textSha256": "8616fbb6414716b9dce266cf9536503cfc80c758f1f056491fe72619b4dfd73d",
      "priorPdfSha256": "68c7e61823d8dd1540e1b8ce61ce3da99d601f032e4ea22825eba224a78c4d32",
      "newPdfSha256": "68c7e61823d8dd1540e1b8ce61ce3da99d601f032e4ea22825eba224a78c4d32",
      "limit": "PDF bytes differ; extracted text matches. No authenticity or current-treatment certification."
    },
    "mataSubstantivePassages": "Opinion pp.1\u20132: gatekeeping role and bad-faith qualification; p.34 conclusion (a)\u2013(d): notices and joint-and-several penalty. No claim that AI use alone caused sanctions or that citation conduct caused dismissal.",
    "garner": "Court-authored opinion text retrieved using web research tool. Existing source PDF retained as CJ-SRC-01; Rule 40 outcome and \u00b610 n.4 intent distinction preserved. Direct HTTP mirror retrieval returned 403; no retry. No exhaustive subsequent-treatment review.",
    "graphRelationships": "CJ-LG-01 hasDetermination resolves to CJ-LG-02; CJ-LG-02 source resolves to CJ-LG-10 and anchors resolves to CJ-LG-03; CJ-LG-03 corresponds to Human Oversight explanatory page CJ-LG-04.",
    "coverage": "CJ-LG-05 #coverage-review exists; Oct 14, 2026 is the published comparison date, not a new legal review date.",
    "illustration": "CJ-LG-12 contains the role labels and responsibility qualification shown in image 2; screenshot capture time remains unknown."
  }
}